Mystery Puzzles

Browse our fantastic selection of mystery jigsaw puzzles available here in our online puzzle store. These puzzles feature mind-bending images that offer a unique and increased challenge in finding the place for each puzzle piece. With subjects like M.C. Escher’s Architect’s Riddle, these brain-teasers are sure to keep you guessing from the first piece to the last!

We offer jigsaw puzzle brands that make quality products; brands like Serendipity, Educa, Masterpieces, Sunsout, and White Mountain that use great materials and sharp, colorful images. Mystery jigsaw puzzles also make great gifts for serious puzzlers!


0 matching items.

There are no products matching the selection.

What sets us
apart from

  • Free Standard Shipping* on all orders $60.00 or more!

    read more
  • Site and Product Reviewsfrom REAL Customers!

    Read them all here.
  • Same Day
    on orders placed before 4pm EST, M-F!

    read more
  • Customer Service
    in just a moment's notice, 9am to 5:30pm EST M-F!