Customer Favorites - 95 Results

Discover products that are popular from customers like you.

#1

1000 Pieces

Halloween Witches

$16.76 $20.95 20% Off

#2

1000 Pieces

Stained Glass Tree of Life

$19.95

#3

Best Peel & Stick Glue Sheets

$14.95

#4

Puzzle Glue

$6.95

#5

1000 Pieces

Autumn Welcome

$16.76 $20.95 20% Off

#6

1000 Pieces

The Dress Shop

$21.95

#7

500 Pieces

Heartland - Crookshanks Magical Elixir

$16.95

#8

500 Pieces

Country Escapes - The Puzzle Shed

$16.95

#9

1000 Pieces

Fireworks on the Mountain

$21.95

#10

1000 Pieces

On the Boardwalk

$21.95

#11

500 Pieces

Barn and Owls

$21.95

#12

500 Pieces

Fright Night Friends

$15.16 $18.95 20% Off

#13

1000 Pieces

Witch's Cauldron

$16.76 $20.95 20% Off

#14

1000 Pieces

Fields Department Store

$21.95

#15

500 Pieces

Halloween Doors

$15.16 $18.95 20% Off

#16

1000 Pieces

If You Dare

$17.56 $21.95 20% Off

#17

Best Puzzle Roll-up

$16.95

#18

1000 Pieces

Spooky Night Jigsaw Puzzle

$16.76 $20.95 20% Off

#19

500 Pieces

Halloween Pals

$13.56 $16.95 20% Off

#20

1000 Pieces

Halloween House

$21.95 Special Price In Cart

#21

500 Pieces

Circle of Colors - Ocean

$25.95

#22

300 Pieces

An American Birdhouse

$16.95

#23

1000 Pieces

Autumn In The City

$21.95 Special Price In Cart

#24

300 Pieces

Glow in the Dark - Ready for Treats

$13.56 $16.95 20% Off

#25

1000 Pieces

Beach House

$21.95

#26

New 1000 Pieces

Christmas Baking

$21.95

#27

1000 Pieces

Autumnal Bliss

$21.95 Special Price In Cart

#28

500 Pieces

Blooming Summer Bouquet

$22.95

#29

550 Pieces

Fall Frenzy

$13.56 $16.95 20% Off

#30

1000 Pieces

Magic Store

$15.96 $19.95 20% Off

#31

1000 Pieces

Irish Pub

$20.95

#32

1000 Pieces

Japanese Garden in Bloom

$19.95

#33

500 Pieces

Mom's Diner

$16.95

#34

1000 Pieces

Halloween Mashup

$15.96 $19.95 20% Off

#35

500 Pieces

Heartland - Antiques on Main Street

$14.36 $17.95 20% Off

#36

550 Pieces

Rock & Rolla Diner

$16.95

#37

500 Pieces

Whimsical Town - My Happy Place

$16.95

#38

1000 Pieces

Autumn Harvest

$16.76 $20.95 20% Off

#39

550 Pieces

Heartland - Snowball Ambush

$16.95

#40

500 Pieces

4th of July

$17.95

#41

300 Pieces

Snowy Afternoon Friends

$16.95

#42

The Puzzle Box Stand Blue

$15.95

#43

500 Pieces

Halloween Terrors

$13.56 $16.95 20% Off

#44

The Puzzle Scoop

$15.95

#45

500 Pieces

All Hallow's Eve

$13.56 $16.95 20% Off

#46

1000 Pieces

Let's Go Fishing

$20.95

#47

300 Pieces

Mountain Hideaway

$16.95

#48

500 Pieces

Northern Lights

$16.95

Theme 55

Pieces 5

Item Type 14

Brands 11

Customer Favorites - 95 Results

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8

#9

#10

#11

#12

#13

#14

#15

#16

#17

#18

#19

#20

#21

#22

#23

#24

#25

#26

#27

#28

#29

#30

#31

#32

#33

#34

#35

#36

#37

#38

#39

#40

#41

#42

#43

#44

#45

#46

#47

#48

Cart Summary